No matter how carefully and congenially you run your business, customer disputes will likely happen from time to time.

Some of the complaints may be people looking to negotiate a discount, “game the system” or even outright defraud you. But others could be legitimate complaints arising from mistakes on your company’s part, technological glitches or, perhaps worst of all, fraudulent actions by a third party.

Whatever the case may be, you can protect your business’s reputation and even strengthen its brand by creating and maintaining an effective customer dispute resolution process that includes eight key features:

1. Easily accessible channels of communication. Post easy-to-find and clearly written directions on your website, social media accounts and other channels detailing how customers can report problems, suspected errors and fraud on their accounts. The directions should include up-to-date contact info for your company and identify any forms or documentation required. Also provide a succinct description of your dispute resolution process, so customers know what to expect.

2. An efficient timeline. Naturally, it’s imperative to respond as quickly as possible to customer concerns or complaints. Today’s technology allows businesses to immediately send automated replies confirming receipt of the customer’s message and assuring the sender that you’re investigating. If the matter appears legitimate, you can follow up with a resolution timeline stating the next steps in the process.

3. Empathy and understanding. Train employees to listen patiently and acknowledge to customers the inconvenience of potential errors or fraud on their accounts. Remind customer-facing staff to keep open minds and not automatically assume any customer is making a false report.

4. Rigorous investigatory techniques. Thoroughly investigate disputes to ascertain root causes. Precisely how you should do so will depend on the nature of your industry and operations, as well as the specifics of the complaint.

To ensure consistency and build a robust document trail, however, require employees performing investigations to first gather all available account information and transaction records. Investigators should also carefully preserve emails and other electronic messages, as well as record or transcribe phone conversations with complaining customers and, if applicable, other involved parties.

5. Strong data protection. Your business should already have up-to-date cybersecurity safeguards in place to prevent data breaches and identity theft. But your customer dispute resolution process should include additional layers of protection. For example, apply “the principle of least privilege,” which means, in this case, only authorized employees directly involved in investigations have access to pertinent data.

6. Transparency and proactive follow-ups. Keep customers informed throughout the entire process. Don’t “leave them hanging” and wait for them to follow up with you. Provide them with regular updates on investigations and inform them of outcomes as soon as they’re available.

7. Timely resolution. If a dispute is found to be in the customer’s favor, quickly make the necessary corrections — such as refunds or account adjustments. Also consider providing a temporary discount, free replacement items or complementary services. Many companies also issue an apology, though you may want to consult your attorney on the language.

If you deny a claim, provide a detailed explanation of the evidence and your reasoning. Consider allowing some customers to appeal decisions not in their favor by submitting supplemental information.

8. Documentation and analysis with an eye on continuous improvement. Last, be sure to continually learn from incidents. Retain records of all customer disputes and fraud claims to identify patterns and trends. Use this data to improve your internal controls and investigatory processes, make decisions on technology upgrades, and train customer-facing teams. By doing so, you may be able to prevent disputes in the future or at least lessen their frequency.

© 2024

Polk & Associates

Large enough to serve a diverse clientele, yet small enough to maintain a hands-on approach, we are committed to maintaining the highest accounting and ethical standards with continuous education, extensive research resources, and excellent quality control.

Polk and Associates is a member of the Michigan Association of Certified Public Accountants, and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. The firm participates in the AICPA Peer Review Program, and has always received the highest level of award for its audit practice and quality control.